Posted in

Should I start all seeds in seed trays?

If you’ve ever wandered through a nursery on a sunny Saturday, watching folks tuck packets of tomato or basil seeds into their shopping carts, you’ve probably heard at least one person ask: “Should I start all my seeds in seed trays?” As someone who’s spent the last eight years in the seed tray supply business, I’ve answered that question hundreds of times—usually with a follow-up that depends less on gardening trends and more on what grows well, where you’re growing, and how much patience you’re willing to bring to the table. Seed Tray

Let’s start with the basics: seed trays (sometimes called seed starting flats or cell packs) are more than just a convenient way to corral seeds. They’re designed to control variables that can make or break a seed’s first few weeks of life. When you sow directly into garden soil, you’re at the mercy of unpredictable temperatures, erratic rainfall, and tiny pests that can nibble a seedling before it even unfurls its first true leaves. Seed trays let you create a microclimate tailored to each seed’s needs—warm enough for peppers, slightly cooler for lettuce, with consistent moisture that doesn’t turn your soil into a mud bath. That’s not a small detail; studies from university extension programs show that direct-sown seeds have a 30-40% higher germination failure rate in home gardens compared to tray-started seeds, mostly due to those unregulated conditions.

But here’s the thing I tell every new gardener: starting all your seeds in trays isn’t a one-size-fits-all rule. Some plants simply hate being transplanted. Root veggies, for example—carrots, radishes, turnips—develop long, taprooted systems that don’t tolerate being jostled. If you pry a carrot seedling out of a tray cell to move it to the garden, you’ll likely cut or bend its taproot, leaving it stunted or deformed. For those, direct sowing is non-negotiable, and even the best seed trays won’t change that. Then there’s fast-growing, cold-hardy greens like arugula or spinach. They germinate and mature so quickly (some in as little as three weeks) that the time and effort of transplanting often outweighs the benefits of tray starting. I’ve seen gardeners waste hours pricking out arugula seedlings only to have them bolt a week after planting—hardly a win.

That said, most common garden crops fall into that middle zone where seed trays shine. Let’s talk about tomatoes, for example. I’ve had customers come to me last spring with stories of sowing tomato seeds directly in their raised beds, only to have 2 out of 10 seeds germinate, then half of those get damaged by a late frost. When they switched to trays, they saw germination rates jump to 85%—and because they could harden off the seedlings gradually, those transplants were more resilient when moved outside. Tomatoes also benefit from being started early indoors; in many temperate climates, the growing season is too short to sow them directly and get a full harvest before fall. Seed trays let you get a head start, so you’re not playing catch-up once the last frost date passes.

Another big advantage of seed trays is space efficiency. If you’re working with a small balcony or a tiny backyard, you don’t have room to scatter 50 marigold seeds across your soil—especially when most will never grow to bloom. Trays let you plant 4-6 seeds per cell, thin them to the strongest one, and maximize every square inch of your indoor growing space. Plus, tray systems make it easy to organize your plants: you can label each cell with the seed variety and sowing date, so you don’t mix up your basil and mint, and you can move the entire flat to follow sunlight or adjust its temperature as needed. For home gardeners who don’t have a dedicated greenhouse, that flexibility is priceless.

But let’s be honest, there are downsides to tray starting, too. It requires supplies—trays, soil, grow lights (or a sunny windowsill, which can be spotty), and water. For someone who’s only growing a few herbs on their windowsill, buying seed trays might feel like a unnecessary expense. You also have to stay on top of watering; tray soil dries out faster than garden soil, and if you forget to check for a few days, your seedlings will wilt and might not recover. Transplanting itself is a skill, too. If you don’t handle seedlings gently, you can damage their stems or roots, leading to shock that sets them back for weeks. I’ve had a few customers come to me frustrated because their tray-started plants died within days of planting, only to admit they yanked the seedlings out by the tops instead of teasing them out with a fork. That’s not the tray’s fault—it’s a matter of knowing how to use it.

So when should you skip the trays entirely? As I mentioned, root vegetables are a no-go. Corn, too, is another crop that doesn’t transplant well; its long roots don’t like being disturbed, and germination rates drop sharply when seedlings are moved. Also, if you’re a beginner who wants to test the waters without investing too much time or money, direct sowing some easy crops is a great way to build confidence. Lettuce, peas, and sunflowers germinate reliably and grow fast, so you’ll see results quickly without the learning curve of tray starting. That said, even beginners can benefit from trays for crops like peppers or eggplant, which are slower to germinate and need warmer temps. I always recommend new gardeners start small: pick 2-3 crops you’re excited about, use trays for one of them, and direct sow the rest to compare.

Now, as someone who’s spent years watching gardeners (and their seeds) go wrong, I’ll share a common misconception: bigger trays aren’t always better. For small plants like herbs or leafy greens, a 12-cell tray is perfect—you don’t need a 50-cell flat that’s more than you’ll ever use. For larger plants like tomatoes or peppers, 6-cell or 4-cell trays give the roots enough room to grow before transplanting, without wasting soil or space. We’ve designed our trays with that in mind—our most popular models are the 12-cell for herbs and small greens, and 6-cell for veggies that need a bit more room. The thickness of the tray matters, too; thin, flimsy trays crack easily when you’re moving them, and they don’t hold soil or moisture as well. That’s why our trays are made from durable, BPA-free plastic that can be reused for years—saving you money in the long run, even if you’re starting small.

Another thing to consider: seed trays aren’t just for indoor use. If you live in a warm climate where your outdoor garden is ready to go earlier, you can use trays on a shaded porch to protect seedlings from intense midday sun. Or, if you’re dealing with heavy soil that drains poorly, using trays raised slightly off the ground lets excess water drain away, preventing root rot. That’s a trick many experienced gardeners use—trays aren’t just a starting tool, they’re a flexible growing tool that can adapt to different spaces and conditions.

I’ve seen too many gardeners write off seed trays because they tried a cheap, flimsy set once that fell apart or their seedlings got leggy from not enough light. Leggy seedlings are a common problem with tray starting, but it’s not the tray’s fault—it’s usually a lack of consistent, bright light. Windowsills don’t provide enough light for most seedlings, so pairing trays with a cheap grow light (or even a LED lamp) will give you short, sturdy plants that transplant well. That’s a tip I give every customer: invest in a simple light setup, and your tray-started plants will be far healthier than anything you can direct sow.

So, circling back to the original question: should you start all seeds in seed trays? The answer is no—but you should start most of them, depending on your space, your climate, and your favorite crops. If you’re growing root veggies, fast-growing greens, or want a low-effort first experience, skip the trays. But if you’re growing tomatoes, peppers, herbs, or flowers that need a head start, trays are worth the investment. They reduce germination failure, save space, and give you control over your seedlings’ early growth—skills that will make you a better gardener, no matter what you’re growing.

If you’re ready to try seed trays for your next garden, we’re here to help. Whether you’re a home gardener looking for a small set of trays or a larger operation needing bulk supplies, we can work with you to find the right fit for your needs. Don’t hesitate to reach out to discuss your seed starting goals and find the solutions that work for you.

Venturi Fertilizer Injector References

  1. University of California Agriculture and Natural Resources. (2022). Seed Starting for Home Gardens.
  2. Royal Horticultural Society. (2021). Transplanting Seedlings: Best Practices.
  3. Texas A&M AgriLife Extension. (2020). Direct Seeding vs. Transplanting for Vegetable Crops.

Xiamen Superb Technology Co., Ltd.
Xiamen Superb Technology Co., Ltd. is well-known as one of the leading seed tray manufacturers and suppliers in China. With a professional production team, we are able to meet the needs of the majority of our customers. Please rest assured to wholesale high quality seed tray from our factory.
Address: 1-2F, 1 Building, Xinyongsheng Industry Garden Dianqian, Huli District, Xiamen, China
E-mail: mike@irriga-systems.com
WebSite: https://www.irriga-systems.com/